Tuesday, February 22, 2011

Freedom means free. Most times.

This is hilarious: http://www.illusionmage.com/

This guy Seth Avery is selling software that does 3d imaging. The problem is, this software is GNU GPL, which means open source. Which means free. As in $0. Take a look at the crappy advertising schemes (omg it's only 47 dollars until 3 days from now and then it could be ANY PRICE I WANT!), then head to the very bottom of the screen in very tiny font without any formatting:
"Released Under GNU GPL. Source code available for download."

Now for the 'lawls', (I know, you're thinking 'but geo I already lawlsed' but just wait for it...) the GNU GPL requires that you can sell software all day long if and only if you provide access to the original 'free' version as well: http://www.illusionmage.com/disclaimer.htm
"Source code of these content and files is available to be downloaded from here"

He's selling software for $47 that you can attain for free ON HIS OWN WEBSITE! LAWLS!
Granted, it's packaged as binary so most windows and mac users would have no idea what any of this means.

Okay, so there's a bit of this that's actually not 100% scamming you. Evidently he does include videos on how to work the software, so it may well be worth 50 bucks. And for those of you not familiar with open source, this is completely legal. Read here for more if you're confused at this point http://www.flightgear.org/flightprosim.html ...It's a website about people who work on an open source flight simulation game, and their ordeals with people doing things like what Seth Avery is doing to Blender (aka illusion magic).

Open source software is about freedom, not free software (aka "freeware"). The freedom to do what you want to do with the software you have installed on hardware you have paid for. And this happens a lot with entire linux distributions. People are now taking Ubuntu and making a designer OS just by tweaking the wallpaper, sound theme, window manager, and desktop environment. This is because Ubuntu actually comes with a tool to do this so you can create "Geo's OS". Canonical, the company who distributes Ubuntu, also distributes other flavors of Ubuntu: Xubuntu, Lubuntu, Edubuntu, Mythbuntu, etc. (pretty sure those are all Canonical, it's hard to keep track...) But the difference is these designer linux operating systems, (I can't think of any off the top of my head but I may edit this later and add a few links to some) they aren't stupid enough to try to charge money for them. It's not a legal issue, it's an ethical issue.

And as I said before this Illusion Mage software seems to come with some how-to videos, and that makes it slightly less scammy. As long as people know what they're buying is copyrighted under GNU GPL (and what that means) there's no problem, but this guy is just being shady and using gimmicky marketing schemes. The thing I'm wondering is, if he would market his product as "OPEN SOURCE, FREE SOFTWARE, ZERO DOLLARS" and then sell his tutorial videos for $50, would people buy them? To me this sounds like an awesome marketing point. The software is free. It's complicated to use. I'll GIVE you the software for free, and you can also buy my how-to videos if you want to. What's wrong with this as a business model? Why resort to gimmicks?


Edit: as pointed out on /. (where I found out about the Blender ripoff guy) you can clearly see this is a scam (credit goes to dk3nn3dy):
Your Dinky One-Time Investment Is Only $47!
(This is a special launch offer only, we're only opening this for the next 3 days only before the offer closes forever!)
Thats right. Your investment for the entire course is only $47 (this launch offer will closed anytime after February 26, 2011 )
Where February 26, 2011 is:
days = 3; // How many days to add to today
  d = new Date();
now = d.getTime(); // Add 10 days
d.setTime(now + days * 24 * 60 * 60 * 1000);
document.getElementById("offerEnd1").innerHTML = formatDate(d);
function formatDate(d) {
var months = new Array("January", "February", "March", "April", "May", "June", "July", "August", "September", "October", "November", "December");
return months[d.getMonth()] + " " + d.getDate() + ", " + d.getFullYear();;

No comments:

Post a Comment